Metaphysics, Spring 2017



(LCI) = Loux, Metaphysics: A Contemporary Introduction 

(LCR) = Loux, Metaphysics: Contemporary Readings

(E) = Evnine, Making Objects and Events


Week One: Puzzles about Identity and Time 

  • Week One: A Puzzle about Identity


Weeks Two-Three: Universals 

  • Week Two: Realism
    • Chapter One (LCI) 
    • Loux, ‘The Problem of Universals’  (LCR)
    • Russell, ‘The World of Universals’ (LCR)
    • Price, ‘Universals and Resemblances’ (LCR)
    • Armstrong, ‘Universals as Attributes’ (LCR)
  • Week Three: Nominalism
    •  Chapter Two (LCI)
    • Quine, ‘On What There Is’ (LCR)
    • Williams, ‘The Elements of Being’ (LCR)


Weeks Four-Six: Particulars

  • Week Four: Particulars and Predication 
    • Chapter Three (LCI)
    • Loux, ‘The Ontological Structure of Concrete Particulars’ (LCR)
    • Black, ‘The Identity of Indiscernibles’ (LCR)
    • Allaire, ‘Bare Particulars’ (LCR)
  • Week Five: Bundles
    • Van Cleve, ‘Three Versions of the Bundle Theory’
    • Casullo, ‘A Fourth Version of the Bundle Theory'
  • Week Six: Particular Substances
    • Van Cleve, 'The Moon and Sixpence,' in Contemporary Debates in Metaphysics, ed. Hawthorne, T. Sider, and D. Zimmerman (Blackwell, 2008), 321-40.
    • Wolterstorff, ‘Bergmann’s Constituent Ontology,’ Nous 4 (1970), 109-134
    • Loux, ‘What is Constituent Ontology?’ in L. Novak et al. edd., Metaphysics: Aristotelian, Scholastic, Analytic, 43-57


Weeks Seven-Eight: Modality and Possible Worlds 

  • Week Seven: Possible Worlds 
    • Chapter Five (LCI)
    • Loux, ‘Modality and Possible Worlds’ (LCR)
    • Lewis, ‘Possible Worlds’ (LCR)
  • Week Eight: Actualism
    • Plantinga, ‘Actualism and Possible Worlds’ (LCR)
    • Lewis, ‘Counterparts or Double Lives’ (LCR)
    • Kripke, ‘Identity and Necessity’ (LCR)


Week Nine: Mid-semester Break


Weeks Ten-Thirteen: Identity through Time

  • Week Ten: Time 
    • Chapter Seven (LCI)
    • Loux, ‘Time: The A-Theory and the B-Theory’ (LCR)
    • McTaggart, ‘Time’ (LCR)
    • Broad, ‘Ostensible Temporality’ (LCR)
    • Prior, ‘The Notion of the Present’ (LCR)
    • Mellor, ‘The Need for Tense’ (LCR)
  • Week Eleven: Persistence 
    • Chapter Eight (LCI)
    • Heller, ‘Temporal Parts of Four-Dimensional Objects’ (LCR)
    • Merricks, ‘Endurance and Indiscernibility’ (LCR)
  • Week Twelve: Substance and Life
    • Shields, “The Dialectic of Life,” Synthese 185 (2012), 103-124 


Weeks Thirteen-Sixteen: Constitution, Hylomorphism, and Identity

  • Week Thirteen: The Metaphysics of Hylomorphism
    • (E), Chs. One and Two 
      • N.b. No meeting on 13 April
  • Week Fourteen:  Artefacts 
    •   (E), Chs. Three and Four
  • Week Fifteen:  Living Systems 
    • (E), Ch. Five
  • Week Sixteen: A Final Sailing of the Ship of Theseus


© Christopher Shields 2014